Dennis Haysbert (Self - Narrator), David E. Eisenhauer (Self - Convicted of First Degree Murder), Patrick Jensen (Self - Chief Deputy ommonwealth Attorney, Montgomery County), Natalie Marie Keepers (Self - Convicted of Accessory Before the Fact to First Degree Murder), Nicole Madison Lovell (Self - 2016 Murder Victim: Age 13), Mary Pettitt (Self - Commonwealth Attorney, Montgomery County), Michael Scimeca (Self - FBI Special Agent), Anthony Weeks (Self - Brother of Nicole Madison Lovell), Tammy Weeks-Dowdy (Self - Mother of Nicole Madison Lovell), Travis Witt (Self - FBI Special Agent)